Metavid

Video archive of the US Congress

House Proceeding 03-16-10 on Mar 16th, 2010 :: 2:22:20 to 2:42:20
Total video length: 14 hours 45 minutes Stream Tools: Stream Overview | Edit Time

Note: MetaVid video transcripts may contain inaccuracies, help us build a more perfect archive

Download OptionsEmbed Video

Views:3,996 Duration: 0:20:00 Discussion

Previous speech: Next speech:

Dean Heller

2:21:50 to 2:22:20( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Dean Heller

Dean Heller

2:22:02 to 2:22:21( Edit History Discussion )

Dean Heller: louisiana purchase or the courthouse for kick -- corn husker kickback or gatorade and the list goes on and on. despite the majority's effort to hide this vote, the american people will not be fooled. the american people know the purpose of this health care bill is to make sure all americans have the same bad health care. i encourage my colleagues to

Tom Price

2:22:22 to 2:22:43( Edit History Discussion )

Tom Price: listen to the american people, create bipartisan health care reform and get americans back to work. i yield back. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman's time has expired. for what purpose does mr. rooney from florida rise? mr. rooney: address the house for one minute. the speaker pro tempore: without objection. mr. rooney: madam speaker, i'm astounded by the democrats' blatant abuse of the house rules established in our constitution

Tom Price

2:22:25 to 2:23:25( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Tom Price

Tom Price

2:22:44 to 2:23:04( Edit History Discussion )

Tom Price: by entertaing the possibily of what's known as the slaughter rule. if they choose to deem the senate health care bill law under this self-executing rule without a traditional up or down vote on this actual text they will strip the american people of their rights to checks and balances in a bicameral congress.

Tom Price

2:23:05 to 2:23:25( Edit History Discussion )

Tom Price: and if my colleagues on the other side of the aisle truly believe that this health care bill will solvehe nation's health care problems, then why are they afraid to go on the record and put their names on it? like most americans, i am disillusioned with this congress. we need to go back to the drawing board an focus on

Scott Garrett

2:23:26 to 2:23:46( Edit History Discussion )

Scott Garrett: reducing health care costs when constitutional and not by creating a new entitlement in a backroom deal. ank you and i yield back the balance of my time. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman's time has expired. for what purpose does the gentleman from new jersey rise? >> address the house for one minute. the speaker pro tempore: without objection. mr. garrett: madam speaker, i

Scott Garrett

2:23:30 to 2:24:50( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Scott Garrett

Scott Garrett

2:23:47 to 2:24:07( Edit History Discussion )

Scott Garrett: come to the floor today to speak out e democrats' proposed slaughter solution. this is a sleight of hand with an unconstitutional move to avoid a true vote. younow, article 1 section 7 of the constitution reads, every billhall have passed the house of representatives and the senate before it is presented to the president of the united states. you know, with the slaughter solution leadership is

Scott Garrett

2:24:08 to 2:24:28( Edit History Discussion )

Scott Garrett: attempting to manipulate the rules to circumvent this fundamtal constitutional requirement. in the sate they have a bill there with so many special deals, taxes on insurance, coverage for abortion, even they cannot pass it for a second time. and so democrat leadership here in the house now is trying to avoid a traditional up or down vote. the supreme court has even

Scott Garrett

2:24:29 to 2:24:49( Edit History Discussion )

Scott Garrett: spoken on this and said a bill must contain the exact text before it is approved in one house and then the other in precisely the same text. madam speaker, if we ignore the basic requirements of the constitution, whether by disregarding procedural constraints or oversteing our congressional authority, by dictating people's health insurance, we will descend from

Scott Garrett

2:24:50 to 2:24:51( Edit History Discussion )

Scott Garrett: the freedom of democracy toward

Sheila Jackson-Lee

2:24:52 to 2:25:12( Edit History Discussion )

Sheila Jackson-Lee: the tyranny of a dictatorship. with that i yield back. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman's time has expired. the gentlelady from texas is recognized. for what purpose do you rise? >> address the house for one minute. the speaker pro tempore: without objection. ms. jackson lee: madam speaker, medicare will be expanded, medicaid will be expanded to

Sheila Jackson-Lee

2:24:55 to 2:26:15( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Sheila Jackson-Lee

Sheila Jackson-Lee

2:25:13 to 2:25:34( Edit History Discussion )

Sheila Jackson-Lee: allow more people to be insured, our children will have more health insurance, it will be a major change for america, a positive change. it is interesting that every time america makes a historic and catastrophic change for the better there is large voices of opposition, confused voices, voices without the facts. i'm reminded of the history of

Sheila Jackson-Lee

2:25:35 to 2:25:55( Edit History Discussion )

Sheila Jackson-Lee: the 1964 civil rights act in 19 -- and 1965 voting ri they did not pass in large margins. there were voices of opposition. african-americans should be second class citizens forever. it is time now for the courageous to recognize that americans cannot be second class and third class in the climate of needing health insurance,

Sheila Jackson-Lee

2:25:56 to 2:26:15( Edit History Discussion )

Sheila Jackson-Lee: that they must be able to go to hospitals and not be kicked out, that they must be able to get insurance without saying you have a pre-existing condition, that women cannot be discriminated against. where's the courage to stand up as we did in a time when african-americans needed their freedom? it is now time to free others who do not have health insurance. do you have the courage to make these hard decisions when others

Rob Bishop

2:26:16 to 2:26:36( Edit History Discussion )

Rob Bishop: are chatting away saying the wrong thing? it is time to pass health care refo. i want to stand with the courageous on behalf of the american people. the speaker pro tempore: the gentlewoman's time has expired. for what purpose does the gentleman from new jersey rise? -- utah rise? >> unanimous consent to address the house for one minute. the speaker pro tempore: without objection.

Rob Bishop

2:26:20 to 2:27:25( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Rob Bishop

Rob Bishop

2:26:37 to 2:26:59( Edit History Discussion )

Rob Bishop: mr. bishopmadam speaker, it is very difficult to criticize a bill that is still being put together behind closed doors. but we do know that it is more about consolidation of power in washingtothan about real health reform for american people. we also know that a poor process always equals poor public policy. and the procedural shenanigans being proposed by the speaker

Rob Bishop

2:27:00 to 2:27:20( Edit History Discussion )

Rob Bishop: and democratic leaders to slip this past the american people make all of lucy ricardo's schemes to be a part of ricky's show look like clear and logical plans of action. this also would be a comedy if it wasn't such a tragedy for the american people. madam speaker, my state has already instituted real health care solutions that deal with our demographics and give people options in the state of utah.

Rob Bishop

2:27:21 to 2:27:25( Edit History Discussion )

Rob Bishop: and all of our efforts wi be destroyed if this one size fits

Lee Terry

2:27:26 to 2:27:46( Edit History Discussion )

Lee Terry: all trillion-dollar tragedy is actually passed here on the house floor. i yield back. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman's time has expired. for what purpose does the gentleman from new jersey rise? new jersey. for what purpose does the gentleman from nebraska rise?

Lee Terry

2:27:30 to 2:28:50( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Lee Terry

Lee Terry

2:27:47 to 2:28:09( Edit History Discussion )

Lee Terry: >> unanimous consent to address the house for one minute, revise and extend. the speaker pro tempore: without objection. mr. terry: there will be no straight up and down vote on a health care bill. instead the leadership has chosen a procedural trick to insert the senate bill into a rule deeming the senate bill passed. so if you vote for the rule you

Lee Terry

2:28:10 to 2:28:31( Edit History Discussion )

Lee Terry: are voting for the corn husker kickback, you're voting for the louisiana purchase, language that allows funds to go to abortions. what won't be in this bill is the terry bill amendment that allows people to join the same health care plans that we have as members of congress. why? because it's not controlled by

Lee Terry

2:28:32 to 2:28:51( Edit History Discussion )

Lee Terry: the government and its bureaucrats. yes, this is about government control, where bureaucrats and congress wilbe in control of your health care. and somehow th leadership and authors of these tricks in this bill wonder why the american

Trent Franks

2:28:52 to 2:29:12( Edit History Discussion )

Trent Franks: people don't want this bill. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman's time has expired. for what purpose does the gentleman from arizona rise? >> address the house for one minute. the speaker pro tempore: without objection. mr. franks: thank you, madam speaker. madam speaker, to paraphrase a man, in every child who is born, under no matter what

Trent Franks

2:28:55 to 2:29:55( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Trent Franks

Trent Franks

2:29:13 to 2:29:34( Edit History Discussion )

Trent Franks: circumstances and of no matter what parents, the potentialality of the entire human race is all over again. the democrats say compassion is the fundamental motivation behind this government takeover bill. but if compassion was the motivation, madam speaker, democrat leadership would not be

Trent Franks

2:29:35 to 2:29:55( Edit History Discussion )

Trent Franks: so doggedly determined to include the increased tax-pair funded murder of little unborn - taxpayer funded murder of little unborn children in this bill. nothing so destroys the notion that this bill is about compassion than the arrogant disenfranchisement of those who are helpless and have no voice. it is an unspeakable disgrace.

2:29:56 to 2:30:16( Edit History Discussion )

madam speaker, it is obvious that democrats are determined to ram this bill down the throats of the american people using the so-called slaughter solution, a shameless political gimmick that would avoid even an up or down vote on the bill. but if they do, madam speaker, the world will know that it was never about compassion and democrats will find that they have dangerously underestimated the american people.

2:30:17 to 2:30:37( Edit History Discussion )

the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman's time has expired. for what purpose does the gentleman from texas rise? >> address the house for one minute. . >> thank you, madam speaker. later this week the speaker will ask for a final vote on the bill. the senate bill containa rarefied legislative compromise

Michael M. Honda

2:30:38 to 2:30:58( Edit History Discussion )

Michael M. Honda: as the cornhusker kickback, the louisiana purchase, gatorade, and for the first time ever it allows federal funding for abortions. nevertheless the speaker's asked us to vote on it. i understand my democratic colleagues are being assured the senate will take up the bill fixes if the house will simply pass their bill. i would offer a small word of caution to my friend on the other side of the aisle, once you pass their bill there is

Michael M. Honda

2:30:55 to 2:31:04( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Michael M. Honda

Michael M. Honda

2:30:59 to 2:31:05( Edit History Discussion )

Michael M. Honda: not a guarantee that will be made to force the senate democrats to take up your fix bill and pass it.

Michael M. Honda

2:31:06 to 2:31:14( Edit History Discussion )

Michael M. Honda: the bill that passed out of the senate satisfies 59 sitting senators. the compromise that will pass out of this house will please far fewer. simple logic tells us that the

Michael M. Honda

2:31:10 to 2:31:14( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Michael M. Honda

2:31:15 to 2:31:35( Edit History Discussion )

senate democrats do not have a real and abiding interest in bailing out house democrats for having passed the senate bill. of course simple logic has never been part of this debate. madam speaker, my democratic colleagues are playing a game of chicken with the united states senate. in the end the president might just sign the senate president bill into law along with the louisiana purchase, gador aid, and abortion funding.

John Fleming

2:31:36 to 2:31:57( Edit History Discussion )

John Fleming: the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman's time has expired. for what purpose does the gentleman from louisiana rise? >> i ask unanimous consent to speak to the floor for one min. the speaker pro tempore: without objection. mr. fleming: madam speaker, of this massive 300-page bill, there is not one thing that

John Fleming

2:31:55 to 2:32:55( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: John Fleming

John Fleming

2:31:58 to 2:32:19( Edit History Discussion )

John Fleming: lowers costs. not one. a recent heritage foundation article focused on the fact that the health care system is fraught with perverse economic incentives that generate artificially high and rapidly increasing spending. this system does nothing to incentivize the doctor, the patient, or the insurance

John Fleming

2:32:20 to 2:32:40( Edit History Discussion )

John Fleming: company let alone the federal government to spend the health care dollars efficiently. however, i'm not suggesting that patients have to bear higher out-of-pocket costs. by this the doctor and patient must be reengaged, however, with the cost their care. and how can we do that? one amendment that we have

John Fleming

2:32:41 to 2:32:55( Edit History Discussion )

John Fleming: tried to get into this bill a number of times and failed is a robust system of health savings accounts for all. this way we get to have our cake and eat it, too. by that i mean that a portion of the insurance premiums should be put into a special

Virginia Foxx

2:32:56 to 2:33:16( Edit History Discussion )

Virginia Foxx: medical spending account for all those government and private insurance programs that can be spent at the discretion -- the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman's time has expired. for what purpose does the gentlelady from north carolina se? ms. foxx: permission to revise and extend. the speaker pro tempore: without objection. ms. foxx: yesterday i held a town hall in statesville, north

Virginia Foxx

2:33:00 to 2:33:55( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Virginia Foxx

Virginia Foxx

2:33:17 to 2:33:38( Edit History Discussion )

Virginia Foxx: carolina torques hear from my constituents about health care reform. one thing was abundantly clear, they do not want this bill and they are sick and tired of the backroom deals and provision that is have characterized this process. they wanted health care reform, but they were developmently opposed to the senate bill. -- vehemently opposed to the senate bill. my constituents are asking me if this is such a wonderful

Virginia Foxx

2:33:39 to 2:33:55( Edit History Discussion )

Virginia Foxx: bill why is the majority resorting to tricks and sleight of hand to get it passed? if this bill is so great, why not have a regular vote? the answer is simple. this is not a bill the american people want. some members acknowledge that. madam speaker, we should listen to the american people. we should take an incremental

Peter Roskam

2:33:56 to 2:34:18( Edit History Discussion )

Peter Roskam: approach to health care reform that the american people can support. i yield back. the speaker pro tempore: the gentlelady's time has expired. for what purpose does the gentleman from illinois rise? >> to address the house for one minute. revise and extend. the speaker prtempore: without objection. >> madam speaker, as we are here today on the house floor at this very moment the

Peter Roskam

2:34:00 to 2:35:15( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Peter Roskam

Peter Roskam

2:34:19 to 2:34:40( Edit History Discussion )

Peter Roskam: democratic leadership of the house of representatives is smiling and dialing. they are calling members of congress on the other side of the aisle and cajoling them and coaxing them and urging them to do the equivalent of really political bungee jumping, with you they don't know how long the cord is. you be the first one to jump off, we are going to vote for

Peter Roskam

2:34:41 to 2:35:02( Edit History Discussion )

Peter Roskam: the senate bill and trust in the senate to take it up and fix it. or alternatively even worse, we are not going to have a final vote on this bill. can you imagine a process that is this manipulated, that is at this high stakes literally? the federal government taking over 1/6 of the economy really

Peter Roskam

2:35:03 to 2:35:16( Edit History Discussion )

Peter Roskam: in the twinkling of an eye? it is as if the democrat inc. leaders are telling the american public, look, we have a wonderful plan for your life. you are going to love it. we are going to vote on it and then we'll let you read it. madam speaker, we can do better. the american public demands

Bob Goodlatte

2:35:17 to 2:35:37( Edit History Discussion )

Bob Goodlatte: that we do better to vote no and start over. i yield back. the speaker pro tempore: for what purpose does the gentleman from virginia rise? >> ask unanimous consent to address the house for one minute. revise and extend my remarks. the speaker pro tempore: without objection. mr. goodlatte: i rise today in strong opposition to not only the democrats' health care proposal but to the outrageous process by which the majority intends to ram this bill

Bob Goodlatte

2:35:20 to 2:36:25( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Bob Goodlatte

Bob Goodlatte

2:35:38 to 2:35:59( Edit History Discussion )

Bob Goodlatte: through the house while denying members of coness an up or down vote on the bill. this morning's "cincinnati enquirer" declared what americans all over this country are saying, quote, this disgusting process which democrats brazenly wish to bring to conclusion this week is being done with little regard for the opinions of a clear majority of americans

Bob Goodlatte

2:36:00 to 2:36:21( Edit History Discussion )

Bob Goodlatte: who, while they may believe health care reform is necessary, think this particular approach will take our nation down the wrong economic path. american families want health care reform that will expand access and choices and decrease costs. the democrats' health care bill includes tax increases, medicare cuts, job-killing mandates, and higher premiums. this bill is nothing more than

Bob Goodlatte

2:36:22 to 2:36:25( Edit History Discussion )

Bob Goodlatte: the same government-run insurance mandates and taxes

John J. Jr.Duncan

2:36:26 to 2:36:46( Edit History Discussion )

John J. Jr.Duncan: the american people have overwhelmingly rejected. this bill must be killed. we must start over. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman's time has expired. for what purpose does the gentleman from tennessee rise? >> request permission to address the house for one minute. revise and extend remarks. the speaker pro tempore: without objection. mr. duncan: madam speaker, when i was driving into work last friday, i heard the governor of arizona on the news saying that

John J. Jr.Duncan

2:36:30 to 2:37:30( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: John J. Jr.Duncan

John J. Jr.Duncan

2:36:47 to 2:37:07( Edit History Discussion )

John J. Jr.Duncan: her state, already faces its biggest deficit ever, over $3 billion. she said they had calculated the health care bill would cost an additional $4 bllion that they simply do not have. because tennessee already covers more than most states, our democratic governor nonetheless said it would st our state from $750 million up to $3 billion more.

John J. Jr.Duncan

2:37:08 to 2:37:28( Edit History Discussion )

John J. Jr.Duncan: most states are in far worse shape than tennessee or arizona. yet much of this bill is paid for by forcing millions more on to state medicaid rolls. in yesterday's "washington post," columnist robert soft money samuelsson said the bill, quote, abates health care's major problems and worsen the outlook. it wrote it's a big new spending program when the government hasn't paid for the

John J. Jr.Duncan

2:37:29 to 2:37:30( Edit History Discussion )

John J. Jr.Duncan: spending programs it already has.

Gregg Harper

2:37:31 to 2:37:51( Edit History Discussion )

Gregg Harper: madam speaker, even if this program was the greatest thing since sliced bread, the fact is we simply cannot afford it. i yield back the balance of my time. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman's time has expired. for what purpose does the gentleman from mississippi rise? >> ask unanimous consent to address the house for one minute. revise and extend my remarks. the speaker pro tempore:

Gregg Harper

2:37:35 to 2:38:55( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Gregg Harper

Gregg Harper

2:37:52 to 2:38:13( Edit History Discussion )

Gregg Harper: without objection. >> madam speaker, late last night the house budget committee approved the reconciliation shell bill with two democratic members joing all republicans in opposing this enormous entitlement expansion. and we still do not know what changes the speaker will bring forward. the president has asked congress to hold an up or down

Gregg Harper

2:38:14 to 2:38:35( Edit History Discussion )

Gregg Harper: vote on the senate's so-called health care reform proposal. let's have that vote. the president has argued the democrats need courage to pass this one-size-fits all government takeover of health care. where is the courage in hiding behind procedural chaos like the slaughter solution? no matter what anyone says, a yes vote on the reconciliation

Gregg Harper

2:38:36 to 2:38:55( Edit History Discussion )

Gregg Harper: bill is a vote for the senate trillion dollar bill containg kickbacks like the cornhusker kickback and the louisiana purchase and the allowance for federal funding for abortion. the bottom line is th health care bill so bad that the democrats have to resort to trickery. i will not support a bill that will increase families' insurance premiums and force

Marsha Blackburn

2:38:56 to 2:39:16( Edit History Discussion )

Marsha Blackburn: hundreds of millions of dollars in unfunded mandates to my home state of mississippi. i urge you to oppose this legislation. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman's time has expired. for what purpose does the gentlelady from tennessee rise? >> i ask unanimous consent to address the house for one minute. the speaker pro tempore: without objection. mrs. blackburn: thank you,

Marsha Blackburn

2:39:00 to 2:40:15( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Marsha Blackburn

Marsha Blackburn

2:39:17 to 2:39:37( Edit History Discussion )

Marsha Blackburn: madam speaker. this year i have replaced town hall meetings in my district with listening sessions. i go to hear what my constituents have to teach me and teach this body. they want us to know that e process matters to them. some of my colleagues like to say that it doesn't make any difference, but my constituents

Marsha Blackburn

2:39:38 to 2:39:58( Edit History Discussion )

Marsha Blackburn: know that when legislation is negotiated in the back rooms, that america loses. they know that in the backrooms , stimulus bills turn into pork bills. bailout bills and energy bills turn into taxes. today hundreds of americans are walking the halls of this

Marsha Blackburn

2:39:59 to 2:40:15( Edit History Discussion )

Marsha Blackburn: building asking us to stop this outrageous government takeover of health care. and take health reform step by step and structure a system that gets them out of this broken system, not locks them into it permanently.

Robert Latta

2:40:16 to 2:40:36( Edit History Discussion )

Robert Latta: i hear them, madam speaker, and i certainly hope that this chamber hears them. i yield back. the speaker pro tempore: the gentlelady's time has expired. for what purpose does the gentleman from virginia rise? >> madam speaker, request permission to address the house for one minute. the speaker pro tempore: without objection. >> i'm hearing loud and clear

Robert Latta

2:40:20 to 2:41:30( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Robert Latta

Robert Latta

2:40:37 to 2:40:58( Edit History Discussion )

Robert Latta: from people's america's first district in virginia that this health care bill before us will not reduces, will not increase acess, and full of sweetheart backroom deals that they find highly objectionable and that now we are proposing to put ?"this bill through without having to directly vote on the bill. that also makes them mad.

Robert Latta

2:40:59 to 2:41:20( Edit History Discussion )

Robert Latta: let me tell you what they are saying. jimmy from yorktown says we are very concerned with the direction congressional leadership is taking with health care reform. it is apparent congress is not listening to the american people. we understand the need to address health care reform, however, congress must include fiscal responsibility in any reform legislation. congress needs to listen to the

Robert Latta

2:41:21 to 2:41:31( Edit History Discussion )

Robert Latta: american voter and taxpayer instead of holding our views in contempt. there are many other people from the first district that have very similar views. i urge my colleagues to vote no.

Phil Gingrey

2:41:32 to 2:41:54( Edit History Discussion )

Phil Gingrey: let's listen to the american people, listen to tir concerns, and do the right thing. with that i yield back. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman's time has expired. for what purpose does the gentleman from georgia rise? >> madam speaker, to address the house for one minute. revise and extend. the speaker pro tempore: without objection. mr. gingrey: madam speaker, one day after the health care summit at the blair house, peggy noonan wrote in the "wall street journal," and i quote,

Phil Gingrey

2:41:35 to 2:42:25( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Phil Gingrey

Phil Gingrey

2:41:55 to 2:42:15( Edit History Discussion )

Phil Gingrey: what the meeting made clear is what the democrats are going to do. not step back and save the moderates of their party but attempt to bully a bill through the congress. this is boorish of them and they will suffer for it. indeed, madam speaker, i think the democrats will get slaughtered for it.

Phil Gingrey

2:42:16 to 2:42:25( Edit History Discussion )

Phil Gingrey: but unfortunately the collateral damage is to the health of the american people. i ask all my colleagues join with me and my constituents in the 11th congressional district

Personal tools

MetaVid is a non-profit project of UC Santa Cruz and the Sunlight Foundation. Learn more About MetaVid

The C-SPAN logo and other servicemarks that may be found in video content are the property of their respective trademark holders. None of these trademark holders are affiliated with Metavid