Metavid

Video archive of the US Congress

House Proceeding 03-25-10 on Mar 25th, 2010 :: 0:12:20 to 0:32:20
Total video length: 3 hours 58 minutes Stream Tools: Stream Overview | Edit Time

Note: MetaVid video transcripts may contain inaccuracies, help us build a more perfect archive

Download OptionsEmbed Video

Views:2,821 Duration: 0:20:00 Discussion

Previous speech: Next speech:

Joe Courtney

0:11:10 to 0:12:20( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Joe Courtney

Joe Courtney

0:12:13 to 0:12:21( Edit History Discussion )

Joe Courtney: with a choice of private health insurance plan, comprehensive benefits no rescissions, no lifetime limits, no annual limit, that's what we're giving

David Dreier

0:12:22 to 0:12:35( Edit History Discussion )

David Dreier: to the american people, what members of congress have. it's time to move forward and end the days of haves and have nots. i yield back. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman from california. mr. dreier: thank you very much, mr. speaker.

David Dreier

0:12:25 to 0:12:35( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: David Dreier

0:12:36 to 0:12:57( Edit History Discussion )

i'm happy to yield one minute tohe member from athens, georgia, another of our able medical doctors, mr. broun. the speaker prtempore: the gentleman is reck recognized for one minute. mr. broun: this bill, as well as the underlying bill, are a farce. go big farces. let me tell you a couple of things they won't -- two big farces.

Paul Braun, Jr.

0:12:58 to 0:13:09( Edit History Discussion )

Paul Braun, Jr.: let me tell you a couple of things they won't do and will do. it's going to drive millions of people out of work. also, besides that, it's going to drive many doctors business, amr. burton was

Paul Braun, Jr.

0:13:00 to 0:13:09( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Paul Braun, Jr.

Paul Braun, Jr.

0:13:10 to 0:13:24( Edit History Discussion )

Paul Braun, Jr.: talking about. when people have that free insurance card issued by the federal government in their pocket, it's going to be about as worthless as the confederate doctor was after the civil war you won't find many doctors

Paul Braun, Jr.

0:13:20 to 0:13:24( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Paul Braun, Jr.

Paul Braun, Jr.

0:13:25 to 0:13:45( Edit History Discussion )

Paul Braun, Jr.: willing to take the government insurance card. access will be worse. it's going to be worse for the people who can least afford it to be, that's the poor people in this country as well as senior citizens. we need to repeal this bill we need to stop this reconciliation process farce tonight we need to repeal

Paul Braun, Jr.

0:13:30 to 0:14:10( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Paul Braun, Jr.

Paul Braun, Jr.

0:13:46 to 0:14:08( Edit History Discussion )

Paul Braun, Jr.: obamacare and replace it with something that saves jobs and will -- the speaker pro tempore: the house will come to order. the gentleman is entitled to be heard. please proceed. mr. dreier: i thank -- mr. broun: i thank the gentleman. we need to repeal obamacare and

Paul Braun, Jr.

0:14:09 to 0:14:10( Edit History Discussion )

Paul Braun, Jr.: we need to replace it with

Louise McIntosh Slaughter

0:14:11 to 0:14:20( Edit History Discussion )

Louise McIntosh Slaughter: policy that will create access, create jobs, which will lower the cost of health care and not be a government takeover of the health care system. i yield pack.

Louise McIntosh Slaughter

0:14:15 to 0:14:20( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Louise McIntosh Slaughter

John Hall

0:14:21 to 0:14:41( Edit History Discussion )

John Hall: ms. slaughter: i yield one minute to the gentleman from new york, mr. hall. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman is recognized. mr. hall: thank you, mr. speaker, thank you, madam chair. critics are still screaming at the top of their lungs that it's tyranny a government takeover of health care. these attacks are drowning out the truth. i'd like to set the record straight.

John Hall

0:14:25 to 0:15:20( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: John Hall

John Hall

0:14:42 to 0:15:02( Edit History Discussion )

John Hall: nothing in this law, not even that dreaded washington bureaucrat, will come between you and your doctor. think law does keep insurance company bureaucrats fm denying you care. secondly, we are actually increasing access to private health insurance. in return for those millions of new customers, however, insurance companies must end

John Hall

0:15:03 to 0:15:20( Edit History Discussion )

John Hall: abusive practices like dropping you when you get sick. finally, since this bill has been passed, not one hospital or doctor's office has been taken over by the government and i doubt that one will. there's nothing to suggest that that will happen. that is overblown rhetoric, deceptive and wrong.

Todd Tiahrt

0:15:21 to 0:15:41( Edit History Discussion )

Todd Tiahrt: it's time to start telling the truth -- to start telling the truth anstop spreading fear. i urk my colleagues to pass the final piece of health reform. i yield back. e speaker pro tempore: the gentleman from california. mr. dreier: i'm happy to yield a minute to our friend from kansas, mr. tiahrt. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman is recognized for one minute.

Todd Tiahrt

0:15:25 to 0:17:25( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Todd Tiahrt

Todd Tiahrt

0:15:42 to 0:16:02( Edit History Discussion )

Todd Tiahrt: mr. tiahrt: i thank the gentleman from california. this rule should be brain. -- withdrawn. the senate bill is now law it's the greatest intrusion into our private lives we've seen under this congress. it's going to hurt our economy an cost us jobs. plus there are special provisions within the bill that's been signed into l that should have been corrected in the reconciliation bill but

Todd Tiahrt

0:16:03 to 0:16:23( Edit History Discussion )

Todd Tiahrt: this rule fails to address those corrections that need to be taken. the louisiana purchase is still law today, should have been corrected. the university of connecticut hospital that received an earmark should have been corrected by this underlying legislation. the hawaiian disproportionate share hospital program is exempt from cuts, other states aren't.

Todd Tiahrt

0:16:24 to 0:16:45( Edit History Discussion )

Todd Tiahrt: tennessee is also exempt from d.s.h., the frontier funding in counties in some rural areas are exempt and other rural areas are not. montana receives special benefits for asbestos, what about the other 49 states? and connecticut and michigan have got a handful of hospitals going to get higher medicare patients because of the

Todd Tiahrt

0:16:46 to 0:17:06( Edit History Discussion )

Todd Tiahrt: legislation and this rule fails to address it and change the underlying bill so that we can correct these improper motions. i would request that we withdraw the rule and get a proper bill to the floor. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman's time has expired. e gentlewoman from new york. ms. slaughter: may i inquire as to the time remaini. the speaker pro tempore: the

Todd Tiahrt

0:17:07 to 0:17:26( Edit History Discussion )

Todd Tiahrt: gentlewoman from new york has 5 1/2 minutes remain, the gentleman from california has 6 1/2 minutes remaining. ms. slaughter: i will reserve my time. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman from california.

0:17:27 to 0:17:47( Edit History Discussion )

mr. dreier: mr. speaker, may i inquire of my friend how many speakers she has remaining? ms. slaughter: i have three. mr. dreier: three speakers remaining. we don't have that many, i reserve the balance of my ms. slaughter: all right. let me give one minute to the ntleman from california, mr. hinojosa.

0:17:48 to 0:18:09( Edit History Discussion )

the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman from texas is recognized for one minute. mr. hinojosa: thank you, mr. speaker. i rise today in support of this rule and the underlying legislation on health and higher education. i thank my colleagues in the senate for their courage in passing this htoric legislatn this afternoon by

0:18:10 to 0:18:31( Edit History Discussion )

making the single largest investment in financial aid in history, our nation is taking bold steps to ensure acssibility and affordability in higher education for years to come and lead us to prosperity. more affordable student loans, pell grants, scholarships will help students and families pay for college.

0:18:32 to 0:18:53( Edit History Discussion )

i'm proud of investments in $2 billion in community colleges and $2.5 billion in minority-serving institutions will bring us closer to billing a world-class education system for all students. it's estimated that texas will relieve $2.4 billion in pell grants 57bd a toal of $2.8

0:18:54 to 0:19:15( Edit History Discussion )

billion from programs funded in this reconciliation package. university of texas pan american and texas southern university will greatly benefit from this legislation. the speaker pro teore: the gentleman from california. mr. dreier: mr. speaker, at this time, i'm happy to yield three minutes to my very good

Michael C. Burgess

0:19:16 to 0:19:37( Edit History Discussion )

Michael C. Burgess: friend, another medical doctor who is with us here, the gentleman from lewisville, texas, mr. burgess. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman is recognized for three minutes. mr. burgess: i thank the gentleman for the recognition. ironic, isn't it, two days ago a bill was signed that was going to fundamentally transform the way health care

Michael C. Burgess

0:19:25 to 0:22:30( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Michael C. Burgess

Michael C. Burgess

0:19:38 to 0:19:58( Edit History Discussion )

Michael C. Burgess: would be delivered in this country and 48 hours later, we're back on the floor of the house trying to fix the problems in this bill because, mr. speaker, we all know when the senate passed this bill christmas eve, they didn't intend for this bill to become law. this was never the vehicle that was intended to be passed through this house. this was a bill pass to get the senate out of town before a snowstorm on christmas eve.

Michael C. Burgess

0:19:59 to 0:20:20( Edit History Discussion )

Michael C. Burgess: they always planned to come back and fix it in conference but because of an election in massachusetts, those plans went by the wayside. the speaker of the house said in january, i don't have 100 members who will vote for this bill jet somehow, we ended up passing this bill on sunday night when we hoped, we hoped the american people were not

Michael C. Burgess

0:20:21 to 0:20:42( Edit History Discussion )

Michael C. Burgess: looking at us. but we did pass it. now we've got to come back and fix the problems. we'll be back next week and the week after that, this bill will require significant fixes, probably for the remainder of my lifetime on this earth. this was probably the worst product we could have put out for the american people. what about the insurance companies with their stock prices going up.

Michael C. Burgess

0:20:43 to 0:21:03( Edit History Discussion )

Michael C. Burgess: of course they went up. they got everything they wanted. what did they want? they wanted an individual mandate and no public option. guess what, ladies and gentlemen, that's what they got who is standing on the side of the insurance companies? who is standing on the side of the people? i think you've got that wrong. what about far ma, they got everything they -- about

Michael C. Burgess

0:21:04 to 0:21:25( Edit History Discussion )

Michael C. Burgess: pharma, they got everything way want. you have to buy brand name drugs and condition import from overseas. let's not kid ourselves about who was fooling who here. i have asked depr for the white house to give me information on the special deals cut in the white house but we can be the get that information. we get copies of press release we get copies of webpages. the white house has no interest

Michael C. Burgess

0:21:26 to 0:21:47( Edit History Discussion )

Michael C. Burgess: in being transparent in this process because they have so much to hide about this bill. this is a bad bill for america, it's a bad bill for medicine, it's a bad bill for patients. we should do the right thing, come back and try to fix these problems in a real way and don't tell me republicans didn't try, weret there to help. i reached out my hand to the transition team and got it slapped.

Michael C. Burgess

0:21:48 to 0:22:09( Edit History Discussion )

Michael C. Burgess: i reached out my hando my committee chairman and got it slapped. we were there and ready to work, but you weren't interested in working with us. what was the bipartisan nature of the bill? we'll throw it over the transom over july 15, read it quick, we've got a markup in full committee the next day. this bill was never intended to pass this house. the senate passed this bill as a last-ditch ert on christmas

Michael C. Burgess

0:22:10 to 0:22:30( Edit History Discussion )

Michael C. Burgess: eve to get out of town. what have we done? we delivered this bill as the law of the land to the american people and they are correctly outraged by what they see. you had some experience back in 1988 or 1989, you passed a bad catastrophic care bill, seniors across this country said, this will not stand. the former chairman of the ways and means committee got run out

Sheila Jackson-Lee

0:22:31 to 0:22:52( Edit History Discussion )

Sheila Jackson-Lee: of his town halls and we had to repeal that bill. i ink we should follow the same trajectory here. i yield back the balance of my time. ms. slaughter: i yield one minute to the gentlelady from texas, ms. jackson lee. the speaker pro tempore: the gentlewoman is recognized for one minute. ms. jackson lee: mr. speaker, i

Sheila Jackson-Lee

0:22:35 to 0:24:25( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Sheila Jackson-Lee

Sheila Jackson-Lee

0:22:53 to 0:23:13( Edit History Discussion )

Sheila Jackson-Lee: have good news and i thank the gentlewoman from new york. while my colleagues are talking about process, which has been approved by a parliamentarian, and while profanity rains on our phones, we're saving lives. 45,000 who have died every year because they have not had insurance. no doctors offices have closed,

Sheila Jackson-Lee

0:23:14 to 0:23:34( Edit History Discussion )

Sheila Jackson-Lee: the hospitals are open and the attorney generals are filing frivolous lawsuits. because if they would look at what the bill stands for and the present bill, they'll know that the seniors' doughnut hole will be closed, that the special des have bn taken out, that community health centers that will allow you to come out of your house, walk down the street

Sheila Jackson-Lee

0:23:35 to 0:23:56( Edit History Discussion )

Sheila Jackson-Lee: and go to a physician's office is expanded by $11 billion, they'll understand that medicaid has been expanded and right now individuals, 133% to 400% of poverty, can actually go and see a doctor. maybe the mother who has insurance that only covers the emergency room can now get her children preventative care. while they cry into the

Sheila Jackson-Lee

0:23:57 to 0:24:17( Edit History Discussion )

Sheila Jackson-Lee: darkness, we're saving lives. vote for this reconciliation bill to save lives. the speaker pro tempore: the gentlewoman's time has expired. the gentleman from california. mr. dreier: mr. speaker, may i inquire how much time is remaining on each side? the speaker pro tempore: both sides have 3 1/2 minutes remaing. mr. dreier: may i inquire of the diinguished chair of the committee on rules how much time

Sheila Jackson-Lee

0:24:18 to 0:24:25( Edit History Discussion )

Sheila Jackson-Lee: she has remaining, mr. speaker? ms. slaughter: i have one more speaker. mr. dreier: one more speaker and then you plan to close? ms. slaughter: as soon as you have.

Robert E. Andrews

0:24:26 to 0:24:46( Edit History Discussion )

Robert E. Andrews: mr. dreier: then no more speakers other than your close, is that it? ms. slaughter: i have one more speaker and then i hope that you will close and then i will close. mr. dreier: ok, i'll reserve the balance of my time. ms. slaughter: i'm pleased to yield two minutes to the gentleman from new jersey, mr.

Robert E. Andrews

0:24:35 to 0:26:35( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Robert E. Andrews

Robert E. Andrews

0:24:47 to 0:25:07( Edit History Discussion )

Robert E. Andrews: andrews. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman is recognized for two minutes, without objection. mr. andrews: i thank the speaker, i thank the gentlelady. the american people very clearly want bipartisanship but equally clearly they don't want paralysis. they've had 40 years of talk about solving this problem and now they want it solved.

Robert E. Andrews

0:25:08 to 0:25:29( Edit History Discussion )

Robert E. Andrews: at the blair house summit the minority said it would be a good idea to have new ways to cut back on fraud and abuse in medicare. so it's in the law the president signed on monday and in this underlying bill as well. the american people -- minority said they'd like a way for small businesses to pool together and make it easier to buy health insurance.

Robert E. Andrews

0:25:30 to 0:25:50( Edit History Discussion )

Robert E. Andrews: so it's in the law the president signed on tuesday and it's in the bill tonight. the minority said that they'd like to find a way that people could buy insurance across state lines. so the bill tonight says that the exchanges can be regional across state lines so people can buy and sell that way. the minority said they'd like to

Robert E. Andrews

0:25:51 to 0:26:11( Edit History Discussion )

Robert E. Andrews: see a way to cut back on lawsuits so it's in the bill the president signed on tuesday. there are many good ideas from both sides in this bill and on the law signed on tuesday but the best idea is to finally act after 40 years of promises, 40 years of powell tix, 40 years -- politics, 40 years of paralysis, 40 years of inaction.

Robert E. Andrews

0:26:12 to 0:26:33( Edit History Discussion )

Robert E. Andrews: isn't it time that people can't get turned away because they have pre-existing conditions? isn't it time that hardworking americans can afford health insurance? isn't it time that seniors can finally get th pescription dr coverage? the question tonight is whose time is it? it's time for the working families and seniors of america,

Robert E. Andrews

0:26:34 to 0:26:43( Edit History Discussion )

Robert E. Andrews: it is time to end the paralysis,

Charles B. Rangel

0:26:40 to 0:28:10( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Charles B. Rangel

Charles B. Rangel

0:26:44 to 0:27:04( Edit History Discussion )

Charles B. Rangel: end the politics and vote yes. ms. slaughr: did i misspeak, mr. rangel has come and i'd like to give him -- i guess i have a minute and a half left. mr. dreier: i reserve the balance of my time. ms. slaughter: all right, let me yield a minute to mr. rangel, the gentleman from new yk. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman from new york is recognized for one minute. mr. rangel: thank you, madam chairperson. on this historic occasn, i

Charles B. Rangel

0:27:05 to 0:27:25( Edit History Discussion )

Charles B. Rangel: guess those of white house who served so long in the congress hope -- those of us who served so long in the congress hoped and prayed that this night would come. and a lot of us are concerned how we will be remembered. when you reach my age that seems to be a little more important. and on this bill, when you just talk about health care and health reform, it seems to me

Charles B. Rangel

0:27:26 to 0:27:47( Edit History Discussion )

Charles B. Rangel: that now is an opportunity even for those who fought this concept over the years and have fought all the coepts such as medicare and social security, to think about how they would like to be rembered. and i hope that that memory would be that even though the bill was not as perfect as they would want it to be, that they

Charles B. Rangel

0:27:48 to 0:28:08( Edit History Discussion )

Charles B. Rangel: did vote for health reform because that means congresses that follow us the same way we followed those who created social security, those that created medicare, will have the opportunity to improve upon it. so we're not saying that this is the best legislation ever, we're saying this is the best and only oprtunity that we have now.

Charles B. Rangel

0:28:09 to 0:28:11( Edit History Discussion )

Charles B. Rangel: so i do hope that when the final

David Dreier

0:28:12 to 0:28:32( Edit History Discussion )

David Dreier: vote is taken that we'll have it as a bipartisan vote. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman's time has expired. the gentleman from california. mr. dreier: mr. speaker, may i now inquire of the distinguished chair of the committee on rules if she has three or four more speakers? i don't know, mr. speaker, if the distinguished chair of the committee on rules has any remaing -- ms. slaughter: i have no further speakers. mr. dreier: ok.

David Dreier

0:28:15 to 0:32:20( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: David Dreier

David Dreier

0:28:33 to 0:28:53( Edit History Discussion )

David Dreier: i just wanted to clarify that. mr. speaker, i yield myself the balance of the time. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman is recognized for 3 1/2 minutes. mr. dreier: mr. speaker, thank you. i'm going to close the debate as i began by denouncing the charges and smears that we have seen over the past several weeks .

David Dreier

0:28:54 to 0:29:15( Edit History Discussion )

David Dreier: tragically those of white house serve as members of congress for years have dealt with that -- of us who serve as members of congress have for years dealt with that and it's outrageous. mr. speaker, there is a high level of frustration over the process through which we have gone and there is an undersndable outrage from

David Dreier

0:29:16 to 0:29:37( Edit History Discussion )

David Dreier: people all across this country for the final work product that we have. the process has been at very best, i'm trying to be generous, unorthodox. the notion of utilizing rec sill yigs which is de-- reconciliation which is designed to reconcile budget

David Dreier

0:29:38 to 0:29:59( Edit History Discussion )

David Dreier: discrepancies for this is not the right thing to do. and it has never ever, since passage of the 1974 budget empower act, been used for su a monumental piece of legislation. we have tried desperately to work in a

David Dreier

0:30:00 to 0:30:20( Edit History Discussion )

David Dreier: everyone talks about this, but, mr. speaker, we have reached out, as mr. burgess said, time and time again and we have been rebuffed. the only thing bipartisan about this legislation and the vote that we will see tonight, mr. speaker, is not the support for it but the opposition to it.

David Dreier

0:30:21 to 0:30:41( Edit History Discussion )

David Dreier: our colleagues on the other side of the aisle have a 70-seat majority and yet many of their members will be joining us as they did last sunday night i opposing this. why? because they know that this is badly flawed legislation. it's badly flawed legislation because, as we listen to so many

David Dreier

0:30:42 to 0:31:07( Edit History Discussion )

David Dreier: medical doctors point out -- listened to so many medical doctors point out, we're told you can choose your own doctor, we constant thank refrain from the president and others, but the -- hear that refrain from the president and other doctors. but will your doctor choose you? and then, mr. speaker, we get to the question of, will we or will we not be able to pay for this?

David Dreier

0:31:10 to 0:31:31( Edit History Discussion )

David Dreier: well, $1 trillion, $500 billion in tax increases and tremendous uncertainty is not going it adequately address the challenges that we have. we all want to ensure that no one is denied access to health care because of pre-existing conditions. we can do that in a bipartisan way, but, mr. speaker,

David Dreier

0:31:32 to 0:31:54( Edit History Discussion )

David Dreier: unfortunately this bill doesn't do that. there are people out there who today believe that they will not be denied access to insurance because of pre-existing conditions, but, guess what? because this bill was so poorly put together, right now they are denied access. we want to make sure and we're happy to work in a bipartisan

David Dreier

0:31:55 to 0:32:15( Edit History Discussion )

David Dreier: way to address that concern. as we look at the fact that we're back here tonight, because of those two amendments there were problems in the senate, the fact that we already have announced problems with the goal of ensuring that everyone has access, is not deniedccess because of pre-existing conditions, and when we look at

David Dreier

0:32:16 to 0:32:20( Edit History Discussion )

David Dreier: the challenges that have been put forward time and time again,

Personal tools

MetaVid is a non-profit project of UC Santa Cruz and the Sunlight Foundation. Learn more About MetaVid

The C-SPAN logo and other servicemarks that may be found in video content are the property of their respective trademark holders. None of these trademark holders are affiliated with Metavid