Metavid

Video archive of the US Congress

House Proceeding 12-15-09 on Dec 15th, 2009 :: 0:58:55 to 1:18:55
Total video length: 3 hours 43 minutes Stream Tools: Stream Overview | Edit Time

Note: MetaVid video transcripts may contain inaccuracies, help us build a more perfect archive

Download OptionsEmbed Video

Views:2,118 Duration: 0:20:00 Discussion

Previous speech: Next speech:

Lois Capps

0:58:35 to 0:58:55( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Lois Capps

Lois Capps

0:58:52 to 0:58:56( Edit History Discussion )

Lois Capps: gentlewoman has 11 1/2 minutes remaining. and the gentlewoman from tennessee has 14 minutes

Eliot L. Engel

0:58:57 to 0:59:18( Edit History Discussion )

Eliot L. Engel: remaining. mrs. capps: at this time it's my pleasure to acknowledge and yield to the congressman from new york, mr. engel, 2 1/2 minutes. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman from new york is recognized for 2 1/2 minutes. mr. engel: thank you, mr. speaker. i want to thank my colleague from the health subcommittee and energy and commerce subcommittee, lois capps, who is a leader on issues like this.

Eliot L. Engel

0:59:00 to 1:01:50( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Eliot L. Engel

Eliot L. Engel

0:59:19 to 0:59:41( Edit History Discussion )

Eliot L. Engel: i want to commend debbie gentlewoman from florida, for her courage and in talking personally, as well as congresswoman sue myrick for speaking personally. this is dazz that affects so many americans and their families personally. i rise in strong support of

Eliot L. Engel

0:59:42 to 1:00:03( Edit History Discussion )

Eliot L. Engel: this resolution. as the second most common cancer among women in the u.s. and the leading cause of cancer deaths for women under 60, breast cancer is an issue that resonates with us all. the recent changes in recommendations for breast cancer screening made by the u.s. preventative service task force on november 14 have been

Eliot L. Engel

1:00:04 to 1:00:24( Edit History Discussion )

Eliot L. Engel: and consternation nationwide. i can say quite frankly that i was extremely concerned that news reports related screenings would cause some women in their 40's to no longer get mammograms annually for breast cancer. i think what was announced was a mistake. this would really be a travesty if women were prevented from

Eliot L. Engel

1:00:25 to 1:00:46( Edit History Discussion )

Eliot L. Engel: getting mammograms annually. we know that the decline in breast cancer death rates since 1990 are primarily attr uble to early detection -- attribute ute -- attributable to early detection. it was in part due to expanded access to mamography.

Eliot L. Engel

1:00:47 to 1:01:07( Edit History Discussion )

Eliot L. Engel: although these tools arnot perfect they the american medical association, susan b. komen for t mammograms starting at 40, not 50. they never meant to sen message that women should not

Eliot L. Engel

1:01:08 to 1:01:28( Edit History Discussion )

Eliot L. Engel: get breast cancer screenings but women should consult with their personal physicians about the preventatives, risks and limitations on mammography. they admitted at a hearing this mess in the media. i therefore again commend the gentlewoman from florida for her resolution today and really

Eliot L. Engel

1:01:29 to 1:01:50( Edit History Discussion )

Eliot L. Engel: her work all year guided by her personal experience to improve education and awareness and the benefits of breast cancer screeling screening. the -- cancer screenings.

Marsha Blackburn

1:01:51 to 1:02:05( Edit History Discussion )

Marsha Blackburn: we recently markethe 25th anniversary of the national breast cancer awareness month which celebrated great strides. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman's time has expired. mr. engel: and i urge support of the resolution. the speaker pro tempore: th

Marsha Blackburn

1:01:55 to 1:02:05( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Marsha Blackburn

Mike Rogers

1:02:06 to 1:02:26( Edit History Discussion )

Mike Rogers: gentlen's time has expired. the gentlewoman from tennessee. mrs. blackburn: thank you, mr. speaker. at this time i yield three minutes to the gentleman from michigan, mr. rogers, who has been a leader in the health care debate on our energy and commerce committee. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman from michigan is recognized for three minutes. mr. rogers: thank you, madam. thank you, mr. speaker. i want to thank debbie

Mike Rogers

1:02:10 to 1:06:10( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Mike Rogers

Mike Rogers

1:02:27 to 1:02:47( Edit History Discussion )

Mike Rogers: wasserman schultz to talk about her illness. i am a cancer survivor. and it's a grave process. our concern is what is the actual result of that health care reform bill that leads us to this resolution. we are scrambling around on the floor today to say that a government appointed commission, this task force,

Mike Rogers

1:02:48 to 1:03:10( Edit History Discussion )

Mike Rogers: has made a recommendation based on quality of year lives and cost, not good science, not between 40 and 49 need not get mammograms. and you say, listen, that doesn't mean rationing, it doesn't anything, it doesn't have a weight at all. but guess what, the health care

Mike Rogers

1:03:11 to 1:03:31( Edit History Discussion )

Mike Rogers: reform bill that passed this house makes those recommendations law. let me reaa couple quick things, mr. speaker, if i may. in one section -- and by the different sections, two different complete books to understand how this impacts real women in america, some 2,000 pages into it. one section. limitation on individual health insurance coverage may only be

Mike Rogers

1:03:32 to 1:03:52( Edit History Discussion )

Mike Rogers: offered on or after the first day of year one as an exchange participating health care plan. pretty fancy washington speak. let me tell you what it means. in another section of the bill about 1,000 pages later, a health plan is prohibited from offering coverage for benefits not included in the essential benefits package.

Mike Rogers

1:03:53 to 1:04:14( Edit History Discussion )

Mike Rogers: and you say, oh, that's a floor. it's not a floor. the language in the bill goes on further. you know what it does? it says the only difference between the levels of plans is the amount of cost sharing. not what it covers. here's the scary part of which i don't think you all realize that you did to about 47,000 women in america.

Mike Rogers

1:04:15 to 1:04:37( Edit History Discussion )

Mike Rogers: all recommendations of the preventive services task force and the task force preventive services day before the date or enactment of this act and shall they must use that in the calculation of benefits. guess what? 47,000 women who are under the

Mike Rogers

1:04:38 to 1:05:00( Edit History Discussion )

Mike Rogers: age of 50 tay will be diagnosed with late-stage brea bill. it's in your bill. it's in your language. you know what that means? 80% of them mortality rate -- excuse me -- will die because of their diagnosis. do you know tha

Mike Rogers

1:05:01 to 1:05:22( Edit History Discussion )

Mike Rogers: will die because of this bill, than we lost men in the korean war? oh, you think, scare tactics. no, it's the bill. you know what, you can't read it on page 1 or 2. you have to keep going back and forth. in 2,000 pages to understand the full impact of what will happen to wom who are 40 to 49 years old. you did it in your bill.

Mike Rogers

1:05:23 to 1:05:43( Edit History Discussion )

Mike Rogers: i am going to plead with you for the lives of 37,000 women who will die and 47,000 recommendations of this task force which you make law, will be diagnosed -- additional 30 seconds, if i may. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman's time has expired. mrs. blackburn: i yield the gentleman an additional 30 seconds.

Mike Rogers

1:05:44 to 1:06:04( Edit History Discussion )

Mike Rogers: mr. rogers: i am gog to plead with you. please, read the bill. not just 1 to 2,000. and understand its full impact. and you say it won't happen in america. guess what, this task force recommendations resulted on december 2 for california prohibiting low-income women under the age of receiving mammograms. it's happening today.

Mike Rogers

1:06:05 to 1:06:11( Edit History Discussion )

Mike Rogers: this task force is doing it today. with your bill it becomes law. they are prohibited and i illegal for them to get

Lois Capps

1:06:12 to 1:06:32( Edit History Discussion )

Lois Capps: coverage other than what the government says they can get. and guess what, mammograms don't qualify for women 40 to 49. please, think of those women and those familie the speaker pro tempore: the chaireminds members that they are to address their comments to the chair. the gentlelady from california. mrs. capps: thank you, mr.

Lois Capps

1:06:15 to 1:07:05( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Lois Capps

Lois Capps

1:06:33 to 1:06:54( Edit History Discussion )

Lois Capps: speaker. i would remind my colleagues that at the hearing two weeks ago at the energy and commerce committee, the breast cancer stake holders were asked a simple question. would h.r. 3962, the health reform bill, help women with breast cancer? every witness on that panel, including the american cancer society, komen, the national breast cancer coalition, the american college of physicians,

Lois Capps

1:06:55 to 1:07:05( Edit History Discussion )

Lois Capps: every witness on the panel agreed that this bill, the health reform bill, will help women to prevent and women who already have breast cancer.

Jerrold Nadler

1:07:06 to 1:07:26( Edit History Discussion )

Jerrold Nadler: and at this point i am very pleased to yield two minutes to my colleague and big supporter of the breast cancer jerry nadler. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman from new york is recognized. mr. nadler: i thank the gentlewoman for yielding. mr. speaker, i rise today in support of the resolution offered by our colleague, representative wasserman

Jerrold Nadler

1:07:10 to 1:09:05( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Jerrold Nadler

Jerrold Nadler

1:07:27 to 1:07:47( Edit History Discussion )

Jerrold Nadler: schultz. with this solution, which has the -- should have the ful support of the house, would be on record with our commitment not to allow women over 40 to go without the life-saving screening tests currently available to address breast cancer at early stages. and we will have continued research into better tests so that no woman will face a death

Jerrold Nadler

1:07:48 to 1:08:08( Edit History Discussion )

Jerrold Nadler: sentence due to a diagnosis of breast cancer. i thank my colleague, representative wasserman schultz, for bringing this resolution to the floor. but unfortunately this resolution won't cure the potential problem created by or actually highlighted by or by the task force's decision a few weeks ago.

Jerrold Nadler

1:08:09 to 1:08:30( Edit History Discussion )

Jerrold Nadler: even before the recommendations of the task force, and having nothing to do with the recommendations of the task force, many insurance company today deny coverage for screening mammograms to women over 40. . to do -- deal with this be problem, we should pass a bill which i introduced which would legally mandate that any

Jerrold Nadler

1:08:31 to 1:08:51( Edit History Discussion )

Jerrold Nadler: insurance policy that covers diagnostic mammograms must also cover screening mammograms for all women over 40. women over 40 would have legal assurance that is no insurance company would be allowed to denied her coverage for a mammogram. i hope this resolution will serve as a first step toward attaining adoption of mandatory legislation

Jerrold Nadler

1:08:52 to 1:09:05( Edit History Discussion )

Jerrold Nadler: mammography coverage to women over 40 and m.r.i.'s to women who need it because they have a particular genetic or other family history indicating a specific susceptibility to breast cancer. i ask my colleagues to show

Phil Gingrey

1:09:06 to 1:09:26( Edit History Discussion )

Phil Gingrey: their commitment to women's health by voting yes on this resolution and by joining me as a co-sponsor of i thank you. i yield back the balance of my time. the speake gentleman yields back the balance of his time. the gentlewoman from tennessee. mrs. blackburn: yes, mr. speaker. at this time i yield three minutes to dr. gingrey, the gentleman from georgia, who has practiced medicine, obstetrics,

Phil Gingrey

1:09:10 to 1:12:35( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Phil Gingrey

Phil Gingrey

1:09:27 to 1:09:47( Edit History Discussion )

Phil Gingrey: gynecology, has worked with women and women's health care issues and joins us on the energy and commerce committee. i yield to te gentleman. the speak gentleman from georgia is recognized for three minutes. mr. gingrey: mr. speaker, i thank the gentlewoman for yielding. do i rise in full support of my good friend and colleague from florida, representative debbie wasserman schultz, for introducing this resolution. i certainly encourage all of my

Phil Gingrey

1:09:48 to 1:10:08( Edit History Discussion )

Phil Gingrey: colleagues to support it. and i am sure if we have a recorded vote, the vet will be 100% in favor -- vote will be 100% in favor of this resolution. mr. speaker, as my colleague from tennessee, mrs. blackburn, and my colleague from michigan, mr. rogers, both members of the energy and commerce committee, both -- as well as myself at

Phil Gingrey

1:10:09 to 1:10:29( Edit History Discussion )

Phil Gingrey: that hearing when we heard from the american cancer society, when we heard from the other witnesses such as the susan g. komen for the cure organization and in talking with our own specialty society, the american college gynecology, they will continue

Phil Gingrey

1:10:30 to 1:10:51( Edit History Discussion )

Phil Gingrey: to recommend very strongly that women in their 40's continue to be screened, to have mammogram screening, maybe even digital mammogram screening because they are at high risk. mr. speaker, as our colleagues have pointed out, the two -- in our body, victims o cancer, god forbid if they had

Phil Gingrey

1:10:52 to 1:11:13( Edit History Discussion )

Phil Gingrey: not gotten early detect maybe their outcome will not be so great. i think because of early detection the cure is probably almost 100%. so we are at a situation where physicians practicing acros this country, if they are sort of in a catch-22 f. they don't follow these guidelines that

Phil Gingrey

1:11:14 to 1:11:36( Edit History Discussion )

Phil Gingrey: will be passed in this bill, in the senate version, when this united states preventive services task force will no longer be an making recommendations, they will be making law. they will be iss if a physicalian decides my patient's in their 40's, i'm going to go ahead and order a mammogram anyway. that mammogram is suspicious

Phil Gingrey

1:11:37 to 1:11:58( Edit History Discussion )

Phil Gingrey: and it leads to a needle biopsy, which may turn out to be negative but it resultsn a complication such as a breast abscess. that physician, mr. speaker, could be below the standard of government health care. as established by the new massive bill that the democrats want to force on the american public.

Phil Gingrey

1:11:59 to 1:12:21( Edit History Discussion )

Phil Gingrey: i say that i stand here commending representative debbie wasserman schultz and this resolution. i'm in favor of it. but i would also recommend that my colleagues on the democratic side of the aisle instruct their conferees if this bill, this massive health care reform bill, goes to conference. and take this resolution with them and say, look, this is our concerns.

Phil Gingrey

1:12:22 to 1:12:35( Edit History Discussion )

Phil Gingrey: that's my recommendation. that's what my colleagues can do for the women in this country. the 47,000 that congressman mike rogers from michigan was talking about. with that, mr. speaker, i yield back my time.

Joe Donnelly

1:12:36 to 1:12:56( Edit History Discussion )

Joe Donnelly: i thank my colleagues on this side of the aisle for absolutely right as they point out in this legislation what the danger is. i yield back. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman's time has expired. the gentlewoman from california. mrs. capps: mr. speaker, i'm very pleased at this point to yield to our colleague from indiana, mr. donlly, one minute. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman from indiana is recognized for one minute.

Joe Donnelly

1:12:40 to 1:13:30( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Joe Donnelly

Joe Donnelly

1:12:57 to 1:13:17( Edit History Discussion )

Joe Donnelly: mr. donnelly: thank you, mr. speaker. i want to support the resolution and my colleague, debbie wasserman schultz. and support the importance of annual mammograms for women age 40 to 49. i, unfortunately, lost my mom to breast cancer when she was very young and when i was very young. these there's nothing more important

Joe Donnelly

1:13:18 to 1:13:30( Edit History Discussion )

Joe Donnelly: than the health of our moms, our daughters, our wives, our friends, and our sisters. so i support this resolution. i support these annual mammograms.

Leonard Lance

1:13:31 to 1:13:51( Edit History Discussion )

Leonard Lance: so that we thank you, mr. speaker. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman yi lance of his time. the gentlewoman from tennessee. mrs. blackburn: thank you, mr. speaker. at this d a halfo the gentleman from new jersey, mr. lance the speaker p gentleman from new jery is recognized for a minute and a half. mr. lance: mr. speaker, i rise today in support of the resolution offered by the

Leonard Lance

1:13:35 to 1:14:45( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Leonard Lance

Leonard Lance

1:13:52 to 1:14:12( Edit History Discussion )

Leonard Lance: gentlewoman from florida. i thank the gentlewoman from tennessee for her leadership on this issue as well. i recently met with new jersey cancer survivors, cancer care advocates from the susan g. komen for the cure in new jersey, and medical professionals at the steeples chase cancer certainty,

Leonard Lance

1:14:13 to 1:14:34( Edit History Discussion )

Leonard Lance: somerset medical center in new jersey. cat lin of white house station who shared her personal story of being diagnosed in her 40's with breast cancer. i strongly oppose the task force recommendations against yearly screening in women 40 to 49.

Leonard Lance

1:14:35 to 1:14:47( Edit History Discussion )

Leonard Lance: my mother died of breast cancer when my twin brother and which is it. her cancer was diagnosed when she was 47. most disappointing about the task force conclusions is the fact that they come on the

1:14:48 to 1:14:48( Edit History Discussion )

heels of a fall 2009 report

1:14:49 to 1:15:09( Edit History Discussion )

published by the american cancer society indicating a large decline in breast cancer deaths in won under 50. breast cancer continues to be the most common form of cancer in women. we should be promoting a federal health policy of encouraging not discouraging mammography screening and self-examination for women 40 to 49 years of age.

1:15:10 to 1:15:30( Edit History Discussion )

i yield back the balance of m time. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman yields back the balance of his time. the gentlewoman from california. mrs. capps: mr. speaker, i'm now pleased to yield to our colleague from pennsylvania, congresswoman dahlkemper, one minute. the speaker pro tempore: the gentlelady from pennsylvania is recognized. miss dahlkemper: thank you, mr. speaker. i rise today in support of this resolution and i thank congresswoman debbie wasserman schultz for her leadership on

1:15:31 to 1:15:51( Edit History Discussion )

this issue. an issue that defends women across the united states and advocates for their health and well-being. breast cancer is a real caninger to women and their families. -- real dangetory women and their families of the it is -- danger to women and their families. it is not an adversary to be underestimated. more than 40,000 women will

1:15:52 to 1:16:15( Edit History Discussion )

sadly succumb to the disease. some of these deaths can be prevented by regular breast cancer screenings. let me tell you one story of a woman from my own district whose life. sue was diagnosed with breast cancer when she was in her late 40's after an annual mammogram. her doctor told her she had to

1:16:16 to 1:16:39( Edit History Discussion )

choose between a lump extommie and masectomy. she shade shared her journal with a newspaper. she writes, the words ring out unlike anything i have ever experienced before. i find no earning, just feel numb. fum downed and questioning how, when. it was just a routine mammogram. sue survive

1:16:40 to 1:17:00( Edit History Discussion )

she had a mammogram. if she was one of women in my district without health care coverage, which she still be with us today? through passage of health care reform can he wee can ensure the decision for mammogram testing remains between a woman and her doctor. i urge my colleagues to this resolution. i yield back.

1:17:01 to 1:17:22( Edit History Discussion )

the speaker pro tempore: the gentlelady yields back. the gentlewoman from tennessee. mrs. blackburn: at this time i yield a minute and a half to our ranking member ros-lehtinen, from florida. the speaker pro tempore: the gentlelady from florida is recognized for a minute and a half. ms. ros-lehtinen: i thank my good friend r the time. i strongly support the resolution before us, mr.

Ileana Ros-Lehtinen

1:17:23 to 1:17:43( Edit History Discussion )

Ileana Ros-Lehtinen: speaker, put forth by my good friend from florida, congresswoman debbie wasserman schultz, related to breast cancer screening. it is through more effective screening strategies that we will save lives. early detection makes the difference in surviving this terrible as proven by the hiroic fight

Ileana Ros-Lehtinen

1:17:35 to 1:18:35( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Ileana Ros-Lehtinen

Ileana Ros-Lehtinen

1:17:44 to 1:18:05( Edit History Discussion )

Ileana Ros-Lehtinen: we heard this morning, the incredible stories of will and perseverance of our colleagues, congresswoman debbie wasserman schultz, and sue myrick, screening must remain a priority. it must be our mission. almost everyone in unfortunately knows someone who has suffered from breast cancer, but as is becoming more

Ileana Ros-Lehtinen

1:18:06 to 1:18:26( Edit History Discussion )

Ileana Ros-Lehtinen: and more likely, we also know someone who was survived breast cancer. and they have survived breast cancer due to routine screening and early screening and screening for young women. we must remain vigilant in our efforts to educate, to diagnose, and to treat. let us make sure that our

Ileana Ros-Lehtinen

1:18:27 to 1:18:35( Edit History Discussion )

Ileana Ros-Lehtinen: efforts to defeat this terrible disease is not put in jeopardy because insurance companies do not want to pay for routine

Lois Capps

1:18:36 to 1:18:56( Edit History Discussion )

Lois Capps: screenings for young women, screening that could save their lives. thank you, my good friend from tennessee, and i'd you back my remainder of the time. the speaker pro tempore: the gentlelady yields back. the gentlewoman from california. mrs. capps: mr. speaker, may i inquire again the time that remains? the speaker pro tempore: the gentlewoman from california has

Lois Capps

1:18:40 to 1:19:05( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Lois Capps

Personal tools

MetaVid is a non-profit project of UC Santa Cruz and the Sunlight Foundation. Learn more About MetaVid

The C-SPAN logo and other servicemarks that may be found in video content are the property of their respective trademark holders. None of these trademark holders are affiliated with Metavid